5. Product safety plan
Microbial controls for product safety
Process control, micro hurdles and controlling pathogenic contamination
Relevant Food Safety Standards
This article has been written to comply with GFSI recognised schemes, including BRCGS Food Safety, BRCGS Packaging, BRCGS Agents and Brokers, BRCGS Storage and Distribution, FSSC 22000, IFS Food and SQF Food Safety.
Microbial control
Clearly controlling microbial growth is a fundamental aspect of product safety. But bizarrely, it doesn’t feature much in the Standards. It’s mentioned in the product safety plan sections as a hazard that must be in scope for hazard analysis.
If you compare it to foreign body control though – you have much more detail about what’s expected when controlling metal detection for example. You’re not provided with the same level of detail in the Standard, for microbial controls.
The Standards do mention it though – in the process control sections. It’s then up to you, to define what’s required.
Process control
Here’s what the BRCGS Food Standard does say about controls for product safety…
“Processes must be adequately controlled and monitored to ensure that product is produced within the microbial specification. This includes Product Safety Control Points such as temperature, time, pressure and chemical properties.”
Monitoring must be carried out at suitable frequencies based on experience of the reliability of equipment, frequency of process changes, and risk to product safety.
Where process parameters are controlled by in-line monitoring devices (automatic temperature or pH loggers), they must be linked to a suitable failure alert system (audible/visual alarm, machine stop function or product divert system) which is activated when defined parameters are exceeded. This alarm must be tested routinely to ensure that it functions properly, and records must be maintained.
The Standard also mentions that process conditions are often not uniform throughout a chill store or an oven and therefore, validation must identify hot or cold spots – to identify worst-case scenarios.
Combined controls
The IFS standard talks about combined controls. This is because you can’t always implement one microbial control -which 100% controls the safety of the product on its own. Where this is the case, more than one microbial control is needed, which means you’ve combined the controls.
A microbial control is also known as a micro hurdle.
Micro hurdles
A micro hurdle is an element that promotes microbial safety because it makes the environment less favourable for pathogenic growth.
Heat treatment
Heat treatment must comply with relevant legislation.
The time and temperature validation of the heat treatment must take into consideration:
- Maximum throughput or processing speeds.
- Maximum capacity of the equipment.
- Cool spots in the process or equipment.
The validation must assess the effectiveness of the heat treatment on the target microbes.
Data logging of time and temperature must include assessment of the worst-case location, such as the centre of the material.
Chilling
The time and temperature validation of the chilling must take into consideration:
- Maximum throughput or processing speeds.
- Maximum capacity of the equipment.
- Warm spots in the process or equipment.
Data logging to produce cooling curves must include assessment of the worst-case location, such as the centre of the material, container, pallet etc.
The validation must assess the result of the cooling curve and micro modelling, on the target microbes.
Curing and smoking
The type and quantity of curing and smoking materials used, must comply with relevant legislation.
The curing validation must take into consideration:
- The uptake of the cure over time.
- The consistency of the uptake.
- Calculation of the uptake by volume or quantity.
- How processing variations such as coverage or temperature may impact the curing process.
The smoking validation must take into consideration:
- The effect on the target microbes of holding the material within the danger zone temperature range.
- Maximum throughput or processing speeds.
- Maximum capacity of the equipment.
- Variation in temperature across the process or equipment.
The validation must include the manufacturer’s instructions for the materials and equipment used.
Moisture
The validation of the drying process must take into consideration:
- Maximum throughput or processing speeds.
- Maximum capacity of the equipment.
- Drying variations across the processing equipment.
The validation must assess the effectiveness of moisture reduction on the target microbes.
Data logging of time and temperature must include assessment of the worst-case location, such as the centre of the material.
Available water
Where available water is controlled, the validation must take into consideration:
- Variation in recipe control.
- Variation in available water across the batch.
The validation must assess the impact of available water on the target microbes.
pH
When validating pH, inaccuracies in the testing method must be considered when caused by product formulation (such as materials with particulates which cause pH to vary across the material).
Preservatives
The type and quantity of preservatives used must comply with relevant legislation. The validation for preservative use, must include the manufacturer’s instructions for use.
Modified atmosphere or vacuum packing
Materials packed in modified atmosphere or vacuum packed must comply with relevant legislation. The validation must take into consideration the specification of the packaging used.
Microbiology
We have more micro articles that you may find interesting:


Have your say…