In this post we’re going to go through the last two types of test and why we do them; the memory test and the large metal piece test…

The memory test

This test is where you have your 3 test packs and in-between them, you have good product, as shown below.

metal detector memory test

The purpose of this test, is to prove that the metal detector can see metal in the ‘test pack 1’, reject it and then reset itself, so that it can see that there’s no metal in ‘good pack 1’.  Then it has to be able to see and reject ‘test pack 2’, then reset itself so it doesn’t reject ‘good pack 2’ and so on.

If the machine cannot reset itself fast enough, it may also reject the good packs. Plus, we are testing the machine, to make sure it does actually reject the test packs and not, the good packs by mistake, allowing the test packs to go through. So, this means that if the machine does not reject all 3 test packs AND, does not allow all 3 good packs to go through, the test has failed.

It is a common mistake to think that the purpose of the test is only to reject the test packs and that it’s ok for the good packs to be rejected too.  Rejecting the good packs shows that the machine is not set up correctly and so, you’ll get false rejects.

Also note, how there are 3 good packs – the last pack is there to prove that the machine resets itself after test pack 3, if it’s not there, then you’ve not proven that the reset mechanism worked for all 3 packs.  Also, it’s good practice to always have a good pack at the end of the test, as you may find you need this pack to ensure that all the products go through in normal product flow.  You may find that, that last pack is needed to ‘nudge’ the test pack through the detector.

Large piece of metal test

One of the most recent tests to be introduced is the large piece of metal test. This test was introduced to replicate a large piece of metal going through the detector, like a spanner for example.

It seems odd that we’d check that the machine can see a large piece of metal, when we’re already checking the machine with smaller pieces of metal – surely, it’s obvious it’s going to reject?  Well yes, you’re right! But this is where this test is very often misunderstood… 

When a large piece of metal goes through the detector, it causes such as large signal, that this can sometimes send the machine haywire!  This means, that it will reject the large piece of metal, but once that’s gone through the machine may not work as it should anymore.  Which then means, that if a product was to contain metal and go through the machine, it may not be detected and rejected.

So, the key part of this test is that the machine not only sees and rejects the large piece of metal, but actually the most important check – is that it will still see and reject your normal 3 test pieces afterwards.

Passing the 3 test pieces through the machine after this test, is the part that’s very commonly forgotten.  Make sure your procedure is to do this, because otherwise putting a large piece of metal through the machine on its own could cause the machine to break and you wouldn’t even know it!

As always, please add your thoughts to the comments box below – I’d love to hear them.   Please, if you are experienced in this topic too, please add any points that others can learn from.

Have your say…

25 thoughts on “The purpose of the metal detector memory test & large metal piece test…”

  1. Hi,

    thanks for the article which has proved really useful.

    Can you give clarification on whether the “memory test” should be carried out on a belt stop metal detector.

  2. Hello, I wonder if Kassy or anyone else in the Techni-K community can help me. Please bear with me as this is perhaps a silly question.
    In one of our units we have just switched from a metal detector to a metal detector with a check weigher. There is a lot of new information and things to address, but one issue that has come up is related to the large metal test. We include this as one of our fail safe checks at start and end of run, as described above. However, how can we do this without the weight affecting our average and other data on the check weigher? Is there something obvious we are missing, some settings we need to alter or is it something we just adjust ourselves when interpreting the data on the printouts? Any help much appreciated, sorry if I’m being dense but this is new for us so lots to learn! Thanks.

    1. Hi Sophie,
      Great question, and no question is a silly question here! First thing to point out is that you must make sure that your metal detector always takes precedence. So if it contains metal and is the wrong weight, the machine rejects it into the metal reject bin. Then, after that without knowing your exact set up – it’s hard to say. But I would hope that the equipment that you’ve purchased has a way of allowing you to test the metal detector without it being recorded by the check weigher. Can you put it in test mode? There must be a test mode for the checkweigher, so that you don’t record the weights of your tests as part of your batch?
      Kassy

  3. Hi Kassy,
    Just starting to run the large metal test on our equipment (Big Fe, Small Fe, GP1, N-Fe, GP2, S/S, GP3) but finding that we’re getting all of the packs rejected. Other than the commercial impact, does it matter that the good packs are being rejected too as long as all the metal test sticks are being rejected?
    Thanks
    Mike

  4. We do not do a large piece of metal test our justification being that we operate a stop belt system. If the belt stops then everything is checked back to the last good check and normal verification checks performed. Some auditors have been satisfied with this in the past and others not as convince; what are people’s thoughts?

    1. Hi Bill

      My only word of warning would be that the large piece test isn’t to show that the detector works when the large piece of metal goes through it. It’s to prove that it’ll work afterward. Therefore, if you’re going to not do this test – how do you prove that?

      Kassy

  5. Hello,
    thank you very much. this is interesting and easy to follow. Have you any idea, perhaps as to whether during the routine metal detector checks, passing the test standard 3 times for each material (ferrous, non ferrous and stainless steel) instead of once would have any significance at all? does it increase machine efficiency or it is redundant since once is enough.

    1. Hi Audrey
      Passing it through more than once won’t have any impact on the machine. It just means you have to have 9 successful results, rather than 3 – so the idea would be that it’s more stringent.
      Although, if the machine saw it the first time – it should see it every time.
      Kassy

  6. Hi. I work at a flour packing plant. We do a consecutive test and memory test. (Engineer does his nut if you call it a memory test – it has no memory, it’s a recovery test!)
    Apparently supermarkets specify ferrous, non ferrous and stainless in that specific order. Now saying that test pieces need to be placed at leading edge – middle – trailing edge in that order. Seems odd as that is giving detector more recovery time and not testing worse case scenario. Can you throw any light or explanation on this??? I fear that someone may have gotten the wrong end of the stick.

  7. Hi Kassy
    There are 2 customer codes of practice which specify the order the test pieces should be in- s/s last in trailing position which contradicts another customer COP which states it should be in the middle pack in the centre. What would your advice be on this? Does one challenge the system more effectively?
    Many thanks in advance
    Julie-Ann

    1. Hi, I’m not aware of any reason why testing the machine in a particular order would make any difference (other than s/s is the most difficult to ‘see’). If you could email me the COPs you’re talking about, I can look into it further for you.
      Thanks
      Kassy

    2. The Test Piece should be placed in the weakest Point in the magnetic field and that is in the middle of the detection gate (normally)

  8. Hi!What I need to do if during my large piece test I have 2 or 3 standard packs rejected which follows after pack with large piece?Count them as metal rejects?

    1. Hi,
      Thanks for your question!
      You need to do your 3 piece test (packs with test pieces in) after the large metal piece – to prove that the machine is still working. If it starts rejecting standard packs then there is something wrong with it and it needs attention.
      Thanks
      Kassy

  9. Surely a saturation test gives a better idea of if your metal detector is working correctly along with this more than the annual test carried out by companies employed to come in and do exactly what operators activities are showing every hour/half our.
    also seeing if the detectors can be challenged to detect smaller particulates below the thresh hold of the current test pieces.

    1. Hi,
      Can you please give us a bit more detail on what a saturation test is? I’ve not heard that terminology before…
      Thanks
      Kassy

  10. This is really helpful. I have never really know what is meant by the memory test and have never even considered the effect a large piece of metal could have on the units! I think a rewrite of the metal detection procedure is now on the cards!

    1. would you do the large metal test every time you test your sample pieces of would you do it say once a week?

    1. Hi, thank you for your comment, we will be writing about BRC V8 in the forthcoming articles – so I think these should help you. Thanks, Kassy

Share your thoughts…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *