The standards

This article is written to meet the following sections of the Standards:

BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 5.3 Management of allergens
BRCGS Packaging Issue 6 4.9.3.3, 4.9.3.4 Management of allergens
BRCGS Agents & Brokers Issue 3 Not applicable
BRCGS Storage & Distribution Issue 4 7.7 Management of allergens
FSSC22000 Version 5.1 2.5.2 Product labelling
IFS Food Version 7 4.19 Allergen risk mitigation
SQF Edition 9 2.8 Allergen management

The requirements

Procedure

All allergens present on site must be controlled to ensure that they do not contaminate product, where they are not listed on the ingredient declaration.

Allergens should not be seen as a whole, i.e. the prevention of cross contamination from allergen containing products from non-allergen containing products.  But also for example, that a milk containing product must be prevented from contaminating a nut containing product and vice versa.

Where materials are unpackaged, a full risk assessment is required to identify the controls. Where products are packaged, a reduced risk assessment can be completed, which focuses on the risks of damage and cross-contamination due to spills.

Where risks are identified, controls appropriate to the level of risk must be determined, documented and implemented.

The risk of cross contamination can be reduced through the use of the following techniques:

  • Physical segregation of allergenic containing materials.
  • Systems to restrict the movement of airborne dust containing allergenic material.
  • The use of separate or additional protective overclothing when handling allergenic materials.
  • Cleaning.
  • Segregation of allergen containing materials through time through the scheduling of production.
  • Waste handling.
  • Spillage controls.
  • Restrictions on food brought onto site by personnel.

Even where on-pack warning labels are used, the above controls must be applied where they physically can be as they are minimum good manufacturing practices.

 

Establish the risks

A risk assessment of all raw materials, including additives and processing aids to establish:

  • The presence of allergens contained in the material.
  • The likelihood of contamination by allergens prior to delivery.

This shall include the review of raw material specifications and, where required, the receipt of additional information from suppliers, through questionnaires for example.

The risk assessment must then assess the risks of allergens in work in progress materials, rework and finished products, to determine:

  • The presence of allergens contained in the product.
  • The likelihood of contamination by allergens during processing and handling.
  • The alibi labelling of each product.

 

Assess the risks and identify the controls

The risk assessment must also look at the risk of cross contamination:

  • Through each equipment step in the process.
  • From the use of shared equipment.

The risk assessment must assess the physical state of the allergenic material, as certain materials are more likely to create a high risk of contamination:

  • Powders for example are more likely to be airborne.
  • Sticky or fatty ingredients are more likely to adhere to surfaces if cleaning is not effective.
  • Materials made up of particulates such as nibbed nuts, as they can easily get lodged in equipment.

Where allergens are handled in the form of fine powders, the movement of airborne dust should be minimised by:

  • Using physical barriers to separate areas.
  • Dedicated areas.
  • Closed containers.
  • Extraction.

The location of air-conditioning or fans should be positioned to ensure these do not distribute airborne allergens.

Allergenic ingredients and products must be physically segregated from non-allergenic ingredients and products, through the application of:

  • Dedicated storage areas or dedicated areas within a store area.
  • Dedicated equipment, tools and utensils where possible.

Where products must be processed in the areas or on the same processing lines, the production runs must be scheduled based on the allergen risk.

All non-allergenic products should be produced before allergenic products, and then allergens introduced to the schedule, in such as way that it minimises the risk of allergen cross contamination.

Production scheduling should be used to minimise the occurrence of changeovers between allergen containing and non-allergen containing products.

Where possible it’s good practice to limit the use of allergens to the end of a shift or production week, followed by a deep clean.

Allergenic materials must be listed on an approved allergen tracker, that is used at material intake, to ensure that materials are handled correctly.

Ideally, allergenic materials will be segregated during storage. However, as a minimum the materials must be segregated where required by customers or where there is a risk of cross-contamination from spillage.

Where materials are not segregated and are stored in packaging which is prone to breakage (such as paper sacks), these materials must be stored at ground level to reduce the risk of contamination if they are to get damaged.

The risk assessment must consider errors made due to accidental use or mix up of ingredients, components or equipment.

Waste which contains allergens should be removed so that the removal process does not become the source of allergen contamination in other areas of the factory.

 

Verify the risk assessment

Check that the risk assessment is accurate, by physically walking the process to ensure all risks have been considered and accurately scored.

 

Create an improvement plan

An allergen improvement plan is required, which addresses any risks, with clear actions, timescales, and responsibilities.

 

Validation

Cleaning validation must be carried out to prove that the cleaning instructions (CICs) work.

The cleaning procedures must be revalidated where there is a change to the procedure, the materials used or the equipment being cleaned.  The cleaning procedure must also be considered when specifying and purchasing new equipment.

 

Determine the remaining risk

Where all possible controls have been implemented and a documented risk assessment demonstrates that there is still a risk of cross contamination, a warning should be included on the label or in the specification.

The use of a warning label isn’t a substitute for good manufacturing practices.

National guidelines or customer codes of practice shall be used when making such a warning statement and where these are used, they must be referenced in the documentation.

Where there is no legislation or customer codes of practice to comply with the following should be considered, to ensure that the warning is clearly displayed on consumer labels:

  • The location of the warning should be in close proximity to the ingredients list.
  • Colour, highlighting and font size should be used to aid visibility of the statement to consumers.
  • The choice of the warning phrase used should be clearly understood by consumers.

 

Change control

The allergen risk assessment must be reviewed annually and following:

  • Any changes to product, materials.
  • If there’s an allergen related complaint.
  • An allergen related incident.
  • A change to allergen labelling requirements.

BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9

5.3.6      This clause has been expanded to state that allergen warning labels must meet relevant legislation. Additional wording has been added for clarity. Points are also added to the items that should be considered, to ensure that legislation and customer requirements are included. The only ‘new’ requirements is that the legislation must be applied for the country of sale.

5.3.7      Additional wording has been added for clarity, but this doesn’t change the requirements of the clause. There’s been a change in terminology from sensitive to food-hypersensitive individuals. The addition of reference to legislation for compliance to the type of claims.

5.3.8      This clause has been restructured and slight wording change. It’s been confirmed that there are no agreed acceptable levels for allergens, but you’d need to base any decisions on what’s required in the country of sale.

Want to implement this topic into your QMS?

This article is part of a series on the subject of contamination control. If you’d like compliant documentation for your management system on this subject, we recommend you purchase our pack.

Contamination control

Pack 6: Contamination Control eDocs

This pack includes a detailed procedure which explains how the allergen risk assessment will be carried out and how the allergen controls will be implemented. Carrying out an allergen risk assessment is a complicated task.

However, the procedure, the risk assessment template and the instructions will walk you through the process, so you can be sure you’ll produce a detailed allergen risk assessment which will get you through any customer audit with ease. You’re also provided with detailed allergen controls, so all you need to do is identify which ones meet your needs, adapt and implement them.

Have your say…

6 thoughts on “Allergen management

  1. Very well documented and written, well done!
    At some point in my tenure, I had to support a process where up to seven allergens (Milk, Wheat, Soy, Fish, Eggs, Peanuts and Almonds) and three sensitizers, at the time, (Sesame, Sulfites and Celery) were present and used in the process. What our team decided to do, was verify risk at every step of the process, From Supplier to Finished product) and if we had appropriate tools (SOP, SSOP, etc.) to deal with potential deviations. After concluding HAZARD ANALYSIS, We also decided to identify accurate Allergen labeling as a CCP, in process HACCP Plan, to bring awareness to fact allergen accuracy declaration and control was imperative.

  2. I believe there is also a confusing issue in the USA that FDA guidance currently lists coconut as a tree nut

  3. Sesame Seed will be included in the list of allergens for the US beginning January 1, 2023. This is an important item of note, because manufacturers using sesame seed or its’ byproducts will need time to implement allergen controls and put warning language in place for any products placed for sale on or after January 1, 2023.

  4. Hi all, great job, you could mention that sesame is being added as the 9th major food allergen in USA – effective January 1, 2023

Share your thoughts…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *