Well – where do we start!  This article, is going to open a whole can of worms (and that’s putting it politely!)

In issue 5 of the packaging standard, the standard was split into two distinct parts; high hygiene and basic hygiene. For issue 6 of the packaging standard, BRC have now combined all the clauses into just one standard.

When BRC produced the clauses of the new issue 6 standard, they used all of the high hygiene clauses to do this.  Not the basic hygiene clauses.

Then, they produced a key changes guide, which helps sites to understand what the changes are from issue 5 to issue 6.  Which is great, because you can then clearly see which clauses are new and so, you can use this to update just the new bits into your systems at site.

The problem

Because the key changes document compares the clauses from the high hygiene section of the standard with the new clause for issue 6, it means that any changes from the basic clauses to the new clauses have been missed.

To explain what we mean, let’s look at an example:

Here you can see in the interpretation guide for issue 5, the high hygiene clause and the basic hygiene clause are shown side by side.


basic hygieneSource: BRC Issue 5 Interpretation Guide

For the same clause, the requirements are different.  The high hygiene clause is more detailed, with the difference shown in yellow marker.

Now, if you look at the Issue 6 Key Changes document for the same clause you can see that BRC have shown that there are no changes.

Source: BRC Issue 6 Key Changes Guidance

Which, if you’re a basic hygiene site, isn’t right – as there are changes between the issue 5 basic clause and the issue 6 clause.

The risk

This means there is a huge risk, of basic hygiene sites missing the changes that are applicable to them, and so, they’re at risk of getting many, many non-conformances in their issue 6 audit.

I’m not sure if BRC have realised, what they’ve done here. My concern is that their training will only focus on the changes highlighted in the key changes document. Which we nearly did, until we realised the problem – so we’ve now had to go back to the beginning and amend the course, to make sure it includes the changes for basic hygiene sites as well.

Moving from issue 5 to issue 6 incurs a lot of work.  Now for basic hygiene sites, this is even more challenging. There are many risk assessments to do, to justify your controls, which we talked about in the previous article: BRC Packaging Risk Assessments galore – 46 to be exact! Plus, reviewing your basic hygiene management system, with the requirements of the high hygiene requirements is going to take a lot of time.

And there’s more problems…

As we’ve gone through the standard to develop our Issue 5 to 6 Packaging Conversion Course, we’ve noticed so many errors and confusing statements, which may cause delays to the implementation.  The most concerning thing we’ve noticed is that there are now requirements in the interpretation guide that are not in the clauses themselves – which is going to really trip people up!

At the time of writing, we’re now only 4 months away from go live for issue 6, there’s not much time…

Help has arrived!

Since this article was published, we have in later articles covered the things we noticed that we thought you needed to be aware of, when updating your systems – to ensure you didn’t fall foul of the problems we encountered.

Now we’ve finished our conversion course, we’ve gone one step further by also producing tools to help you update your systems to issue 6.  Our tools are not a ‘one fits all’ solution, we’ve done one set for basic hygiene sites and one set for high hygiene sites, so that you don’t have to muddle your way through the differences!

We’d love to know your thoughts on this, please add your feedback and comments in the reply box below.

BRC Issue 5 to Issue 6 Packaging Conversion Courses


BRC Packaging risk assessments

BRC Packaging Issue 6 In-House Training
BRC Packaging Issue 6 - Distance Learning
BRC Packaging Issue 6 Distance Learning
BRC Packaging Issue 6 eLearning

Have your say…

2 thoughts on “WARNING!!! If you’re a basic hygiene site – you must read this!

  1. Hey. Could you send me the BRC / IOP Interpretation guide for issue 5, just for knowledge purpose. I will appreciate.

    1. Hi, I’m afraid it’s a paid for document, so I can’t share it due to copyright. If you are a BRC site, you will have access to BRC Participate, where you should be able to download it for free: https://brcgsparticipate.com/signin
      Sorry I can’t be more help, I’d love to be able to send you it…

Share your thoughts…

Your email address will not be published.

We've tagged this article as: